‘Can you sing?’ – ‘Yes I can very well’

Yesterday one of my classes was practicing ‘can’ and ‘can’t’ for ability. One question was something like ‘Can you sing?’. One student wrote ‘Yes I can very well’. Maybe I shouldn’t have worried about so much (or still be worrying about it now), but there was/is something not quite about this sentence.

‘I can sing very well‘ is a perfect sentence. ‘Yes, I /kæn/. I /kən/ sing very well‘, ‘Yes, I /kæn/. Very well’, ‘Yes, I can , very well’, ‘Yes, I /kən/ sing very well’ and ‘Yes, very well’ are all perfect answers. So is ‘Yes[,] I /kæn/ very well’ correct English (in which case, why does it feel so awkward?) or not (in which case, why not?)? (‘Yes[,] I /kən/ very well’ is definitely wrong’.)

Perhaps there is something about ‘short answers with auxiliaries’ (‘Yes, I am’, ‘Yes, I have’, ‘Yes, I do’, ‘Yes, I can’) which precludes there being anything else immediately following, so there must be a longer or shorter pause in speech and a punctuation mark of some kind in writing.

Certainly ‘Yes I can very well’ is not standard English, but equally certainly is perfectly communicative second-language-learner English.

(As an aside, there is a difference between ‘Yes, I can’ and ‘Yes I can’. ‘Yes, I can’ is the answer to ‘Can you sing?’. ‘Yes I can’ is the response to ‘You can’t sing’ (either non-ability or non-permission).)

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s