Two weekends ago our niece treated us to lunch at a Korean restaurant, for a combination of Australian Mother’s’ Day and Korean Parents’ Day (even though we’re not actually a mother and parents). We were sitting within sight and sound of a medium-sized screen playing K-pop girl groups. I got thinking, not for the first time (for example, the previous time we went to that restaurant) how indistinguishable most of the singers, groups and songs are. At least to me, but that might be because I’m a non-Korean man my age and my general unfamiliarity with K-pop girl groups. I could probably say the same about most current-day US/UK/Australian pop music. No doubt they become more distinguishable with exposure and practice.
A few days later I was listening a video of songs of the 1960s, 70s and 80s. One song started which I didn’t recognise but could tell that the singer was Neil Diamond. (Don’t judge me!) A moment later …
Sweet Caroline (Dah dah Dah …)
Oh, that one!
But I have no idea how the chorus goes after that, not even the melody and certainly not the words.
Anyone’s ability to distinguish any music or performers depends on exposure and active, repeated listening. (I tend to listen to music while I’m working, though many classical music videos come with scrolling scores, which I tend to pay more attention to when I’m not working.) Not surprisingly, I’m better at classical music and 1970s US/UK/Australian pop. Two years ago my wife and I were driving in the Blue Mountains. She turned on the radio and I recognised the voice of the presenter (who I know) of Australia’s leading classical music interview/discussion show. He interviewed the author of a book about Beethoven and his milieu and finished with a piece of loud and grand orchestral music. My wife asked me if I knew what it was and I told her Beethoven’s 9th symphony. She said “Are you sure?”. I said “… Yes”.
(A few minutes later) I’ve just listened to Sweet Caroline and realised that I knew the introduction/interlude and vaguely the rest of the chorus, but the verse is still a complete non-memory. I also remembered four chords and originally wrote (da Dah dah Dah).
Related to this is that list videos of No 1/greatest/favourite songs tend to play just the most recognisable part, which is usually the chorus.
Something I used to refer to as first-movement syndrome, where I would be familiar with the final movements of a symphony or concerto but not the first movement, because back when I listened to classical radio a lot, I tended to tune in when such a piece had already started.
I would think differently about group vs. band. In my view a band is more likely to play instruments than a group. Consider the Fifties when we had rock & roll bands and doo-wop groups. That would also explain why we are more likely to see boy bands and girl groups than boy groups and girl bands, but that’s historical in nature and has certainly changed over the last few decades.
I would probably be more familiar with first movements.
Google Ngrams shows that ‘rock group’ took an early lead of ‘rock band’ before the latter took off. Also ‘rock and roll band’ over ‘rock and roll group’ and ‘rock n roll band’ over the not-recorded ‘rock n roll group’.